This is the difference between water based lubricants and oil based lubricants Intimate Talk Silky Smooth Silicone Based Vaginal Lubricant Replens We did lubes. To find the best water based, silicone, hybrid, and oil based ones, we considered ingredients, texture and thickness, scent and taste, and even used at home pH test strips to look Navigating the Slippery Slope: Water Based Lubricant vs. Silicone Base Bed Intentions